Print vs Digital Decodable Readers

1. What Are Decodable Readers?

Before diving into the debate, it’s important to understand what decodable readers are and why they matter. Decodable readers are books specifically designed to align with phonics instruction. They include words that can be sounded out using the letter-sound relationships children have already learned, along with a limited number of high-frequency sight words. This structured approach helps young readers build confidence and fluency as they practice decoding skills in a meaningful context.

Decodable readers are a key component of the Science of Reading, a research-based approach to literacy instruction that emphasises phonics, phonemic awareness, and systematic instruction. Whether in print or digital form, these readers play a crucial role in helping children become confident and proficient readers.

2. Print Decodable Readers: Pros and Cons

Print decodable readers have been a staple in early literacy education for decades. These physical books offer a tactile, hands-on experience that many educators and parents swear by. Here’s a breakdown of their pros and cons:

Benefits of Print Decodable Readers

Tactile Learning Experience for Young Readers

Print books provide a sensory experience that helps children develop fine motor skills and engage more deeply with the text. Turning pages and pointing to words can make reading feel more interactive and rewarding.

Screen-Free Reading for Early Learners

With growing concerns about screen time for young children, print decodable readers offer a screen-free alternative that supports healthy reading habits.

No Digital Distractions During Reading

Print books eliminate the distractions of notifications, ads, or other apps, allowing children to focus entirely on the text.

Accessible Anywhere Without Technology

Print decodable readers don’t require devices, internet access, or electricity, making them a reliable option for classrooms, homes, and on-the-go learning.

Limitations of Print Decodable Readers

Limited Interactive Features for Phonics Practice

Print books lack the audio support, animations, and instant feedback that digital formats can provide, which can be especially helpful for struggling readers.

Higher Costs and Storage Requirements

Print decodable readers can be expensive to purchase in bulk and require physical storage space, which may not be feasible for all schools or families.

Less Personalisation for Individual Learning Needs

Print books are static and can’t be easily customised to match a child’s specific reading level or progress.

3. Digital Decodable Readers: Pros and Cons

Digital decodable readers are becoming increasingly popular as technology transforms education. These e-books and apps offer a range of features designed to enhance the learning experience.

Advantages of Digital Decodable Readers

Interactive Features to Boost Engagement

Digital readers often include audio narration, highlighted text, and interactive animations that make reading more engaging and accessible for young learners.

Personalised Learning Paths for Phonics Success

Many digital platforms, including ePlatform, allow educators and parents to tailor the reading experience to a child’s skill level, selecting difficulty and providing targeted support.

Portable and Convenient for On-the-Go Learning

With digital readers, an entire library of books can be stored on a single device, making it easy to access decodable texts anytime, anywhere.

Cost-Effective Solution for Schools and Families

Digital decodable readers are often more affordable than print versions, with many platforms offering subscription-based models that provide access to a vast library of books.

Challenges of Digital Decodable Readers

Screen Time Concerns for Young Children

Excessive screen time has been linked to issues like eye strain, sleep disturbances, and reduced physical activity, which can be a concern for parents and educators.

Potential Distractions from Digital Devices

Notifications, ads, or other apps on digital devices can distract children from focusing on reading.

Dependence on Technology and Internet Access

Digital readers require access to a device and, in some cases, an internet connection, which may not be feasible for all families or schools.

4. Print vs. Digital: Which is Better for Your Child?

Choosing between print and digital decodable readers depends on your child’s needs, your resources, and your educational goals. Here are some key factors to consider:

Age and Developmental Stage of Your Child

Younger children, especially those in preschool or kindergarten, may benefit more from the tactile experience of print books. Older children who are comfortable with technology might enjoy the interactive features of digital readers.

Learning Environment and Accessibility

If you’re teaching in a classroom with limited access to devices, print books may be more practical. For remote learning or one-on-one tutoring, digital readers can be a great option.

Budget and Resource Considerations

Print books can be costly and require storage space, while digital readers often offer a more cost-effective solution with greater flexibility.

Child’s Preferences and Learning Style

Some children may prefer the feel of a physical book, while others might be more engaged by the interactive features of a digital reader. Pay attention to what works best for your child.

Balancing Print and Digital for Optimal Learning

You don’t have to choose one over the other. A balanced approach that incorporates both print and digital decodable readers can provide the best of both worlds, catering to different learning styles and situations.

— Happy Reading!

Back to blog